The Paint Spot Judgment
What happened
promisedocumented During 2014, Trump Endeavor obtained paint materials for the Doral project under a payment obligation to The Paint Spot.
- Florida Third District Court of Appeal: Trump Endeavor 12, LLC v. Fernich, Inc. d/b/a The Paint Spot, Opinion2017-04-12 · Factual background, 2014 supply transactions and payment obligation
actiondocumented After nonpayment, The Paint Spot recorded a construction lien for $32,535.87.
- Florida Third District Court of Appeal: Trump Endeavor 12, LLC v. Fernich, Inc. d/b/a The Paint Spot, Opinion2017-04-12 · Lien date and amount in factual background
- Florida Third District Court of Appeal: Trump Endeavor 12, LLC v. Fernich, Inc. d/b/a The Paint Spot, Opinion2017-04-12 · Factual background, 2014 supply transactions and payment obligation
outcomedocumented The appellate court affirmed liability and entitlement to attorney fees after the supplier prevailed below.
- Florida Third District Court of Appeal: Trump Endeavor 12, LLC v. Fernich, Inc. d/b/a The Paint Spot, Opinion2017-04-12 · Holding and conclusion
administration responsereported Trump told Reuters that his businesses disputed invoices when work was deficient and paid when contractors did good work.
- Reuters: Special Report: Trump's art of the deal - dispute your bills2015-11-13 · Trump interview response and contractor-dispute examples
Amounts and affected parties
paymentPaint Spot Unpaid Principal$32,535.87 unpaid principal - Ordered from
- Trump Endeavor 12, LLC
- Ordered to
- Fernich, Inc. d/b/a The Paint Spot
- Financially affected
- Fernich, Inc. d/b/a The Paint Spot
People and organizations
- Fernich, Inc. d/b/a The Paint Spotaffected party
- Fernich, Inc. d/b/a The Paint Spotbeneficiary
- Trump National Doral projectbeneficiary
- Trump Endeavor 12, LLCpayer
- Fernich, Inc. d/b/a The Paint Spotrecipient
Assessment
The Paint Spot matter is an adjudicated example of a small supplier forced to use a lien and litigation to collect, but it cannot validate every other contractor claim.