Tiny Red HandsBack to selected case

Trump Winery's 2017 Guest-Worker Applications

Trump Winery's 2017 Guest-Worker Applications

unresolved
Promised
Trump said the administration would buy American and hire American.Open cited record · 1 source
The record
Trump Winery sought permission to employ foreign vineyard workers through the H-2A program.Open cited record · 2 sourcesDepartment of Labor disclosure data record the application within the legal agricultural guest-worker system.Open cited record · 1 source
Who gained
  • Trump Winery
Who paid
  • Trump Winery H-2A workers
  • Potential United States vineyard workers
Audit finding
unresolved

The application creates a documented slogan-to-business-practice contrast, but it does not establish illegality, a shortage of willing U.S. workers or a personal hiring decision by President Trump.

Causal strength: not established

Evidence chronology

  1. promisedocumented

    Trump said the administration would buy American and hire American.

    Open underlying ledger entry
  2. actiondocumented

    Trump Winery sought permission to employ foreign vineyard workers through the H-2A program.

    Open underlying ledger entry
  3. outcomedocumented

    Department of Labor disclosure data record the application within the legal agricultural guest-worker system.

    Open underlying ledger entry
  4. limitationreported

    The winery was controlled by Eric Trump, and the application does not prove that qualified U.S. workers were displaced.

    Open underlying ledger entry

Responses, legal status, contrary evidence, and limitations

  • limitation

    The winery was controlled by Eric Trump, and the application does not prove that qualified U.S. workers were displaced.